NOW PITCHING . . . FOR THE GARGANTUANS - February 11, 2010
Few would dispute the historic significance of April 15, 1947 when then-first baseman Jackie Robinson made his major league debut with the Brooklyn Dodgers at Ebbets Field. His fame was such that just two years later "Did You See Jackie Robinson Hit That Ball?" hit the charts, rising to #13. Many big bands performed that novelty hit but none with more aplomb than Count Basie.
But the the post-WWII Brooklyn Dodgers was not the first racially integrated baseball team. In the 1930s several baseball teams featured white and black players working the field in perfect harmony. That's a pun (I know, it's a pretty bad one) because the these were teams fielded by the big bands!
Throughout the '30s, many bands formed their own teams as a way of relieving the tension of constant touring. Life on the road could be tough, driving day in, day out, often over unpaved roads, sleeping sitting up on the bus and hoping for an occasional hot meal. (Peggy Lee once said that the hardest thing about touring with a big band was learning how to iron her dresses while standing up on a bus riding over country roads.) And the few racially integrated bands had it even tougher as white and black musicians often had to stay in separate — and hardly equal—hotels, use different rest-rooms, and worse.
For some of the bands, baseball was not just for relaxation; it was an obsession. When Harry James left Benny Goodman's great ensemble in December of 1938, one of Goodman's players opined, "We've got other hot trumpets but where do we find a better pitcher?" James once carried season tickets to both the Boston Red Sox and Saint Louis Cardinals, explaining that even though he rarely got to see either team as long as he had the tickets he felt he wasn't missing everything.
During interviews with former members of James's own band I learned that he would tip policemen to reserve a baseball diamond for Saturday mornings in a local park so that the band could take the field to unwind after Friday night shows. Though a pitcher — the team once had a 14-0 record with James on the mound — he was proud of his hitting, competing, while still with Benny Goodman, with drummer Gene Krupa who also swung a mean bat.
The big bands' teams formed an informal league of their own, each team sporting its own monicker. Some are obvious, like Glen Miller's "Millers" and Woody Herman's "Herd". But some are a hoot: Count Basie's "Bad Boys" (also termed the "Bulldogs"), Gene Krupa's "Kangaroos" (alternatively called the "Killer Dillers"), and my personal favorite, Benny Goodman's "Gargantuans". The teams' rivalries equalled those between major league units.
On January 16, 1938, Goodman's band gave the epochal concert at Carnegie Hall, establishing once and for all that Swing was not just dance music but also an art form. Not coincidentally, the show was integrated as members of the Duke Ellington and Count Basie bands performed alongside Goodman's musicians.
That night the smash hits were "Loch Lomond" (earning multiple reprises) and "Sing, Sing, Sing". But I believe — though I cannot prove this — that Goodman allowed only one brief encore at the end of the concert. . . because his team was slated to play against Basie's the next morning!
And they did play that game, with Goodman's team trouncing Basie's. There is a surviving copy of the scorecard as evidence.
While it's fun to imagine the game, years ago I noticed a strange discrepancy. Almost all big band leaders played prominent positions on the field. But not Basie, who was relegated to coaching at 3rd base. As it happens, Basie had been asked about this before and replied that "I've got short arms and legs, can't run, can't hit, can't throw, but I'm OK with coaching 3rd. Hey, any fool knows when to run home!"